Reviewing Books – The Picture of Dorian Gray

Thanks to ShareChair I ordered several classic books along with their audio books for free from Amazon.  You really do need to check out her blog.  It’s all technology, and incredibly organized, every article practical or thought-provoking.

taken from an excellent review of the book – http://salmanlatif.wordpress.com/2011/08/04/the-picture-of-dorian-gray/

Back to books, I just finished my third book from this classic find, and I thought that the least I could do would be to offer a review, something new and fresh.  My review for David Copperfield evolved naturally, and I didn’t search the internet first.  However, before I started writing my next remarkable review I decided to search the internet to find out what others said about  The Picture of Dorian Gray by Oscar Wilde.

I started with Wikipedia, which offered a complete background of the controversy that surrounded the book, the author,  and the characters.  The next site suggested by Google was Sparks Notes.   This was even more complete, but not as easy to stay awake while reading.  It included famous quotes, as well as someone’s explanations to those quotes, study questions and answers.  By this time I was getting so sleepy that I nodded off in the middle of reading, and the page disappeared.  I was ready to finish my search for other reviews – especially since I am not actually having to write a paper or participate in a class discussion.  But I am persistent, I plodded on and looked at the third review source, Goodreads.

I’ve seen the Goodreads sign in the side banner of some websites, but haven’t seen the benefit of them yet.  From the Goodreads reviewers of Dorian Gray I learned that many of them enjoyed Oscar Wilde’s humor in this book.  I am not the fastest reader, but I may be the most distracted one.  This book took me less than a week to finish, as I was reading 2-3 others, but as I read the reviews, I realized that I hadn’t caught some of the nuances that other readers had noticed.

The major nuance should have been as obvious as an uprooted tree lying across the road resulting from Hurricane Sandy’s wrath.  I somehow missed Wilde’s humor entirely in this story about a hedonistic, homoerotic, narcissistic young man, Dorian, and his older guide, Harry, who actually lived the cleaner life.  Actually I missed most of the nuances.  I didn’t notice the fact that he had opium at home, but had to go to the opium dens after he killed his friend, the artist, and had his chemist friend destroyed the body which indicated the depths to which his depravity hit.  I failed to see the symbolic colors used in the novel.

Not only did I overlook the language arts nuances, I failed to note many redeeming historical analysis skills that could be gained from reading this book.  Because psychology is one of the social sciences, a pitch could be made to read this book as a study in psychological disorders.

At the same time I was reading Dorian, I finished the In Search of Bill Clinton:  A Psychological Biography, by John Gartner, the story of another charmingly engaging fellow.  I couldn’t help but compare the two personalities, since both have narcissistic traits.  Clinton managed his, and poor Dorian did not have his skills or moral balance to do the same.  The fictitious character, Dorian Gray, had a true malignant disorder, whereas Clinton was diagnosed as having hypomanic traits which were not malignant.

In spite of all the literary connections which I didn’t recognize, I enjoyed reading the book, and I would recommend it to those who love classics, and a touch of what I would classify as very early science fiction.

I would not recommend it as a literary classic that meets Common Core Standards, AND the standards for History-Social Studies.  Since English teachers only get 50% literature, and need to focus the other 50% of their time on expository reading, I would not waste the student’s precious literature hours on this book.  They can read it when they are on their own as part of a life-long learning program.

I am trying to develop a schedule to my posting, so I write the day before, then polish in the morning before I post.  As I was looking for a good picture this morning, I came across this excellent review o a WordPress site where I got the picture I used.  Click here to read that review.  ShareChair must have inspired many people to read this book because I found several other reviews that have been done in the last month or so, which I included below.  Who knew Dorian would be making such a great come back?

Author: Marsha

Hi, I'm Marsha Ingrao, author, blogger and retired teacher/consultant. Read more about me here. http://wp.me/P7tP3I-2

11 thoughts on “Reviewing Books – The Picture of Dorian Gray”

  1. Thank you for citing my review which, I must say, is not as well-researched as yours. You seem to have read a lot about the book, apart from the book itself, something I often tend not to do which essentially let many a finer themes slip away.
    Indeed the book deals with a number of philosophical themes – to me, it contained some nihilistic hints in it. Your review is quite valuable in that it made me wonder about any other themes that I may have missed. Perhaps I may go back to reading it again with a more focused mind.
    I’ll be looking forward to future book reviews from you 🙂

    Like

    1. I felt the same way about yours. It was the BEST review that I read. I included some at the end of mine that I haven’t read. Thanks for the kind words. I’ll be following your blog. 🙂

      Like

  2. Much Amused by the Clinton/Gray comparison! I may have to make myself re-read it. I’m having trouble going any deeper than Jan Karon or Debbie Macomber lately. Great review!

    Like

  3. Oh dear, I was embarassingly orally euphoric when I popped casually onto your blog and read “Dorian Gray” at the top. I happen to consider Mr. Wilde a dear, dear literary friend, and lament that this was his first and only novel…I hate the way his life really ended quite prematurely after his not so lovely time in Reading Prison. Drives me mad to imagine what we have been pillaged of, had he been able to go on. That rambling aside, I absolutely adore this book. I recently decided Sir should read it as it is so well-written, with such a fluid and lucid quality to it, that I thought Sir might appreciate the writing style alone, if not the story. Another thing that interested me about Dorian Gray is Harry’s name. “Old Harry” is a term for the devil, I thought that most intriguing- he certainly does enjoy corrupting, but never does really do any very notable nefarious deed other than that it seems. A wonderful character. Oh I just love the book, and adore your review here. You inspire me. I may just have to do a review of me own one day soon. I love our Wilde so, and this book is definitely an absolute favourite. I am gaga for his plays and poetry as well. Brilliant, fascinating mind. P.S. Many grins at comparison with Mr. Clinton as well. I so adore and appreciate your blog, and I’m going to check out the blog you link back to here- exciting FREE audio-books of zee classics??! YUS!!

    Like

Your babbling is music to my ears. Please leave a comment!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s